Template:Music ratings/sandbox

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating

Template documentation[view] [edit] [history] [purge]

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[1]
Rolling Stone	9/10[2]

Instructions

This template provides a brief summary and overview of the critical consensus of song and album reviews. It is used to display only brief and objectively-verifiable ratings, such as "", "B+", or "7/10". It cannot capture the general sense of a review that does not include any kind of scale, so do not include language like "Very favorable" or "(mixed)" in the template, as this would be original research.

The template is not to be a substitute for a section in paragraph form, since a review can not be accurately boiled down to a simple rating out of five stars or other numeric score. If an article is lacking a reception section in prose, but the information is presented in table format, the |noprose=yes parameter can be used to tag the article as needing a reception section in prose.

This template is generally the first element after the heading for the section on Reception, Critical reception, Reviews, or something similar. If one of those sections is not present, the template should be placed immediately after the infobox, and can then be moved once a Reception section is present.

The reviews should be listed alphabetically in the Reviews field. The information in the reviewer field should be the name of the source (most commonly an online music service like AllMusic, or a music magazine like Rolling Stone—note that magazines are italicized). Don't forget to wikilink to the relevant article.

The information in the score field should be the rating given in the review (e.g. 4/5). The rating should use the same format as in the review, to portray the score of the review accurately. For star ratings you should use the star rating template; for example, entering {{Rating|4.5|5}}, will render: .

For reviews at AllMusic it is convenient to use the {{AllMusic}} template.

For review aggregators AnyDecentMusic? and Metacritic it is convenient to use the fields ADM and MC in the template, respectively.

For reviews from Robert Christgau's Consumer Guide you may use the Christgau rating template. For example, entering {{Rating-Christgau|dud}} will render: .

Note that the minus sign character (−) is not the same thing as a hyphen (-), so "B–", not "B-". They appear similar but you can use the proper character by inputting − or using the Insert menu that is available in the editing window on Wikipedia; it is located near other such arithmetic operators like <×> and <÷>.

After the rating should be the citation of the source of the review. Per Wikipedia:Citing sources do not add reviews without a citation. This means a properly formatted footnote, in most cases providing the author, date, and source, along with an external link if available. Do not use an embedded link with no information (e.g. link) as this promotes link rot and is inconsistent with Wikipedia's policy on embedded links. If you must use an embedded link, be sure to manually provide a full citation in the article's References section per Wikipedia:Citing sources.

Usage

{{Music ratings
| title = 
| subtitle = 
<!-- Aggregate scores -->
| ADM = 
| MC = 
| aggregate1 = 
| aggregate1score = 
| aggregate2 = 
| aggregate2score = 
| aggregate3 = 
| aggregate3score = 
<!-- ... -->
<!-- Reviewers -->
| rev1 = 
| rev1score = 
| rev2 = 
| rev2score = 
| rev3 = 
| rev3score = 
| rev4 = 
| rev4score = 
| rev5 = 
| rev5score = 
| rev6 = 
| rev6score = 
| rev7 = 
| rev7score = 
| rev8 = 
| rev8score = 
| rev9 = 
| rev9score = 
| rev10 = 
| rev10score = 
<!-- ... -->
<!-- Article needs reviews expanded into prose -->
| noprose = <!--yes-->
}}

Parameters

Required fields:

rev#

The name of the reviewer. It is recommended to include no more than 10 reviews , but you can add more in exceptional circumstances. For instance, a particularly popular song or album which has been re-released and has several prominent reviews over decades' time.

rev#score

The rating given by the reviewer.

All of the following fields are optional:

title

Can be used to provide a custom title for the table, otherwise, it will default to "Professional ratings".

subtitle

Used to add additional text before the collapsible section. This is necessary to add if want a longer title, as long titles via the "title" parameter will not center correctly.

width

Sets the width of the table; default is 24.2em, to match the width of the song and album infoboxes in most browsers and skins.

ADM

AnyDecentMusic? score.

MC

Metacritic score.

aggregate#

Name of a review aggregator.

aggregate#score

The rating given by the review aggregator.

noprose

Should only be used for articles that do not have a Reception section summarizing the reviews. If set to yes, will categorize articles into Category:Articles with music ratings that need to be turned into prose.

Example

For example, entering

{{Music ratings
| MC = 69/100<ref name="Meta">{{cite web|url=http://www.metacritic.com/music/black-gives-way-to-blue/alice-in-chains|title=Black Gives Way To Blue|publisher=Metacritic|access-date=2 September 2012}}</ref>
| rev1 = [[AllMusic]]
| rev1score = {{Rating|4.5|5}}<ref name="AM">{{Allmusic |class=album |id=r70661 |tab=review |label=Alice in Chains: ''Dirt'' > Review |first=Steve |last=Huey |accessdate=31 January 2010}}</ref>
| rev2 = ''[[Q (magazine)|Q]]''
| rev2score = {{Rating|4|5}}<ref name="Q">{{cite magazine |last=Doe |first=Jane |title=Review: ''Dirt'' |magazine=[[Q (magazine)|Q]] |issue=65 |date=February 2002 |page=120}}</ref>
| rev3 = [[Robert Christgau]]
| rev3score = B<ref name="RC">{{cite web |first=Robert |last=Christgau |title=Review: ''Dirt'' |url=http://www.robertchristgau.com/get_artist.php?name=Alice+in+Chains |publisher=[[Robert Christgau]] |access-date=31 January 2010}}</ref>
}}

will render

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Metacritic	69/100
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic
Q
Robert Christgau	B

and generate the following footnotes with the sources:

Tracking categories

• Category:Pages using music ratings with unknown parameters (0)
• Category:Articles with music ratings that need to be turned into prose (11,982)
• Category:Pages using music ratings with duplicate score parameters (0)

Template data

This is the TemplateData for this template used by TemplateWizard, VisualEditor and other tools. See a monthly parameter usage report for Template:Music ratings in articles based on its TemplateData.

TemplateData for Music ratings

This template creates a table with reviews for songs and albums. Only add a rating if you cite it with a reference. The template is not to be a substitute for a section in paragraph form.

Template parameters[Edit template data]

This template prefers block formatting of parameters.

Parameter		Description	Type	Status
1st reviewer	rev1	The name of the first reviewer.	String	required
1st reviewer's rating	rev1score rev1Score	The rating given by the first reviewer.	String	required
2nd reviewer	rev2	The name of the second reviewer. More reviewers can be added with parameters in the format rev[#] (the next one would be rev3). It is recommended to include no more than 10 reviews, but more can be added in exceptional circumstances.	String	optional
2nd reviewer's rating	rev2score rev2Score	The rating given by the second reviewer. More ratings can be added with parameters in the format rev[#]score (the next one would be rev3score). It is recommended to include no more than 10 reviews, but more can be added in exceptional circumstances.	String	optional
3rd reviewer	rev3	no description	String	optional
3rd reviewer's rating	rev3score rev3Score	no description	String	optional
4th reviewer	rev4	no description	String	optional
4th reviewer's rating	rev4score rev4Score	no description	String	optional
5th reviewer	rev5	no description	String	optional
5th reviewer's rating	rev5score rev5Score	no description	String	optional
6th reviewer	rev6	no description	String	optional
6th reviewer's rating	rev6score rev6Score	no description	String	optional
7th reviewer	rev7	no description	String	optional
7th reviewer's rating	rev7score rev7Score	no description	String	optional
8th reviewer	rev8	no description	String	optional
8th reviewer's rating	rev8score rev8Score	no description	String	optional
9th reviewer	rev9	no description	String	optional
9th reviewer's rating	rev9score rev9Score	no description	String	optional
10th reviewer	rev10	no description	String	optional
10th reviewer's rating	rev10score rev10Score	no description	String	optional
AnyDecentMusic score	ADM	The AnyDecentMusic? score. Appears under the "Aggregate scores" header.	String	optional
Metacritic score	MC	The Metacritic score. Appears under the "Aggregate scores" header.	String	optional
1st review aggregator	aggregate1	The name of the first review aggregator.	String	optional
1st review aggregator's rating	aggregate1score	The rating given by the first review aggregator.	String	optional
2nd review aggregator	aggregate2	The name of the second review aggregator.	String	optional
2nd review aggregator's rating	aggregate2score	The rating given by the second review aggregator.	String	optional
Table title	title	A custom title for the table, replacing "professional ratings".	String	optional
Table subtitle	subtitle	Additional text before the collapsible section. This is necessary to add if you want a longer title, as long titles in the "title" parameter will not work right.	String	optional
Table width	width	The width of the table.	String	optional
Table align	align	The value is "left" if you want to place the table on the left. Auto value left	Line	optional
Article lacks prose section	noprose	Set to yes if there is just a single ratings template in the reception section and prose text is missing Auto value yes	Line	optional
Table state (collapse)	state	Automatically collapses the template and adds a "show" button. Suggested values collapsed Auto value collapsed	Line	deprecated

See also

• Template:TV ratings
• Template:Film and game ratings

The above documentation is transcluded from Template:Music ratings/doc. (edit | history)
Editors can experiment in this template's sandbox (edit | diff) and testcases (edit) pages.
Add categories to the /doc subpage. Subpages of this template.